• Login
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Time of Pakistan
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Editorials

Biased verdict in Godhra train carnage case

ToP by ToP
February 25, 2011
in Editorials
0
0
SHARES
7
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

THE case trying suspects involved in the Godhra train carnage of February 27, 2002 in which 59 Karsevaks aboard the Sabarmati Express were burnt to death has been decided. The horrible incident had acted as a catalyst for the genocide in Gujarat, in which incensed Hindu mobs slaughtered over 2000 Muslims in cold blood, raping women and even torching children, while police stood watching helplessly. Gujarat’s Chief Minister Narendar Singh Modi allegedly supervised the massacre, which earned him the dubious title of “The Butcher of Gujarat”. Nine years later, a special “fast track court” court — appointed by the Gujarat High Court on the orders of the Indian Supreme Court — has convicted 31 accused and acquitted 63 others accepting the “pre-planned conspiracy” theory of the prosecution. Pronouncing the judgment in camera in the court held inside the high-security Sabarmati central jail on the outskirts of Ahmadabad, Judge P.R. Patel said a hearing for deciding the quantum of punishment for the convicted persons would be held on February 25. All the 31 accused were held guilty on two major counts — Section 120B (criminal conspiracy) and 302 (murder) of the Indian Penal Code.The judgment appears to be biased and faulty. Interestingly, even while accepting the “conspiracy” theory, the court acquitted at least two of the accused whom the police had all along maintained were among the “main conspirators.” They are Maulana Umarji — who was alleged to have shouted over the public address system fitted in a nearby mosque asking the people of Godhra to rush to the railway station and “kill” karsevaks aboard the Sabarmati Express — and Bilal Hussain Kalota, the then Congress-supported (independent) president of the Godhra municipality, who was claimed to be the main person to have collected the mob outside the rail platform to “set fire” to S-6 coach. The court accepted the “conspiracy” theory on the basis of oral and circumstantial evidence, which is an unacceptable judicial practice, especially where likely death sentence is to be announced for the Muslims accused. The defence counsel has expressed extreme dissatisfaction with the verdict. I. M. Munshi, one of the six-member counsel for the accused, regretted that the court based its judgment on the “evidence” of only four witnesses and an alleged “confessional statement” by one of the accused, which did not merit being “counted.” According to Mr. Munshi, the court heavily relied on the statements by Ajay Baria, a tea vendor on the station platform, and Sikandar Mohammad, who lived near the mosque adjacent to the station and had “rushed” to the platform on hearing the “commotion.”

Both Ajay and Sikandar claimed in their statements given under Section 164 of the Cr. PC that they had actually “seen” the five accused enter S-6 by breaking the vestibule and pour petrol. Two others who gave statements under Section 164 were Prabhatsinh Chauhan and Ranjit Jodha, both employees of the “Bawa” pump. They told the investigating authorities that they had “sold” 120 litters of petrol the previous night to the accused. The only “confessional statement” given by Salim Behra was rendered when the case was being tried under the Prevention of Terrorism Act, which has since been repealed. So the statement given under the POTA would not hold and it should not have been relied upon by the court.The acquittal of Maulana Umarji, whom the police originally held the “principal conspirator,” the prosecution could not produce even an “iota of evidence” against him. The aged Maulana was actually running a relief camp with the permission of the District Collector, following the riots post-Godhra, when the police picked him up. A loudspeaker blaring from the nearby mosque “inciting” the mob was also a “cooked up story” by the police. For, after Umarji, the police named Maulana Abdullah as speaking on the public address system at that time but later it was found that he was not even present at Godhra and was in fact abroad on the fateful day.It is now believed that the 31 convicted would move the Gujarat High Court against the verdict. Such a dubious verdict coming in the Godhra Case only proves the point that the Muslims of Gujarat continue to be persecuted and cannot look forward to getting justice from a biased Hindu court – Dailymailnews

Previous Post

PIAF urges rehabilitation plan for affected traders of Shah Alam fire

Next Post

CDGL to start land deeds by computer

ToP

ToP

Related Posts

Pakistan not surprised by Biden’s intent to review US-Taliban deal
Editorials

Pakistan not surprised by Biden’s intent to review US-Taliban deal

by Jameel Ahmad
January 25, 2021
Pulwama Attack: 10 Questions Indians should ask their Govt, Media
Editorials

Pulwama Attack: 10 Questions Indians should ask their Govt, Media

by Jameel Ahmad
January 20, 2021
Conflict Brewing in the E-Commerce Arena of Educational Products for Children
Editorials

Conflict Brewing in the E-Commerce Arena of Educational Products for Children

by Jameel Ahmad
November 27, 2020
TTP regroups with JuA, HuA in Afghanistan
Editorials

TTP regroups with JuA, HuA in Afghanistan

by Jameel Ahmad
August 19, 2020
Virulence of Bats-Caused Diseases
Editorials

Virulence of Bats-Caused Diseases

by ToP
June 25, 2020
TRUMP’S VISIT INDIA
Editorials

TRUMP’S VISIT INDIA

by ToP
March 3, 2020
Tik Tok Addiction
Editorials

Tik Tok Addiction

by ToP
March 3, 2020
Next Post
CDGL to start land deeds by computer

CDGL to start land deeds by computer

Popular Stories

  • Welcome to Ghas Mandi: Asia’s largest gambling den

    Welcome to Ghas Mandi: Asia’s largest gambling den

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Bodybuilding Champion Found Happiness in God, not Competition

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Watch Video: Indian Father Buried His Ten Year Old Daughter Alive

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Google shuts failed social network Google+

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Time of Pakistan

About Times Of Pakistan

kralbetbetturkeyikimislibahis1xbetm.infohipas.infohttps://www.wiibet.com/restbetcdn.com

Other Categories

  • Beautiful Pakistan
  • Fashion News
  • Funny News
  • Viral Videos
  • Weird News

Recent Posts

  • 11th J.A. Zaman Memorial Open – Powered by Gem Golfers
  • Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to Jail in £190 Million Case
  • World’s Largest Submarine Cable Arrives in Pakistan: Could This End Internet Woes?

Times Of Pakistan © 2024. Design & Developed by E2E Solution Providers.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In