• Login
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Time of Pakistan
No Result
View All Result
Home International News

Analysis: Will battle for Kandahar win the war?

ToP by ToP
August 30, 2010
in International News
0
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

KANDAHAR, Afghanistan — Since the war began, this southern city and surrounding countryside have been marked as the heartland of the Taliban, the insurgents’ springboard to retake all of Afghanistan. It has witnessed some of the bloodiest fighting.

Now, as U.S. and allied forces wrestle with urban warlords and take on die-hard insurgents in booby-trapped orchards and grape fields, the battle for Kandahar is being described as the decisive campaign, a linchpin of American strategy to win the 9-year-old conflict.

“As goes Kandahar, so goes Afghanistan,” has almost become the military’s mantra.

Not all agree, arguing even if success in Kandahar is achieved, the war will be far from over. That success is far from guaranteed: the obstacles are overwhelming, the time to overcome them may prove too short, and victory may hinge not on what happens on the ground in Kandahar, but in the American political arena.

“This is Western military thinking which is totally irrelevant to Afghanistan,” says Marc Sageman, a former CIA operative in the region now with the Washington-based Foreign Policy Research Institute. “You can pacify Kandahar and you’ll still lose the war because Afghanistan remains a highly decentralized society, and in the countryside, the Kabul government has little legitimacy.”

Southern Kandahar is unquestionably important. The city itself, the country’s second largest with some 500,000 inhabitants, served as the capital of the Taliban during its years in power. Al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden used it as his base during the 9/11 attacks. Now, the insurgency draws its greatest strength from the province and the neighboring region, dominated by the Pashtun ethnic majority who form the Taliban core.

“If you win in Kandahar it will have a major effect throughout the south. If Kandahar flourishes, other things will flourish. This is an iconic place for the Pashtun psyche,” the British commander of NATO forces in the south, Maj. Gen. Nick Carter, told reporters recently. In other words, the domino theory, Afghan-style.

Others argue the focus on Kandahar is diverting troops and resources from other areas of the country where the insurgents are making significant gains, that the war, according to some on-the-ground U.S. officers, must be fought village by village, valley by valley.

Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff, has estimated the insurgency has spread to about one-third of the country’s districts. Shadow Taliban governors, some reports say, exist in 33 of the country’s 34 provinces. And there are other strategic hotspots besides Kandahar, including the Kabul region and stretches of the border with Pakistan, where al-Qaida — Washington’s prime target when the war was launched in 2001— is concentrated.

Commanders describe the operation for Kandahar — dubbed “Hamkari Baraye Kandahar,” or “Cooperation for Kandahar” — as not a conventional offensive but rather a “slow, rising tide,” where military muscle plays a secondary role. At its height, roughly 25,000 NATO and Afghan troops will be deployed in the city and surrounding countryside.

“This is not Stalingrad or Fallujah. This fight is about governance, the mobs, the mafia,” Carter said. “Success will be judged how we connect a credible Afghan government to the population.”

But some tough fighting is taking place, with U.S. and Afghan forces concentrated on the city’s western approaches to stem the inflow of fighters, suicide bombers and funds. About 80 percent of one Taliban stronghold, the lush and heavily mined Arghandab Valley, has been secured, Carter says, and next month a major operation will be launched in adjacent Zhari, an insurgency-wracked district where the radical Islamist movement was founded in 1994.

Within the city, “sleepers” have been planted to gather information, and plans call for U.S. military police and the Afghan National Police to have blanketed Kandahar with 11 security stations by the end of September. Intelligence-led operations will target what Carter calls “a resilient insurgency.”

Simultaneously, development projects are to be rolled out, including temporary measures to boost electric power, which is not expected to come on full stream until 2014.

But perhaps the toughest, and most essential, nut to crack will be the parallel, warlord government that has taken root in a vacuum left by the decimation of tribal leadership and the absence of effective Kabul governance. Among several families essentially running the city is that of Ahmed Wali Karzai, the half brother of President Hamid Karzai who has shown little inclination to remove his relative despite widespread allegations of his involvement in racketeering, drug-trafficking and assassinations of rivals. The younger Karzai denies those allegations – Msnbc

Southern Kandahar is unquestionably important. The city itself, the country’s second largest with some 500,000 inhabitants, served as the capital of the Taliban during its years in power. Al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden used it as his base during the 9/11 attacks. Now, the insurgency draws its greatest strength from the province and the neighboring region, dominated by the Pashtun ethnic majority who form the Taliban core.

“If you win in Kandahar it will have a major effect throughout the south. If Kandahar flourishes, other things will flourish. This is an iconic place for the Pashtun psyche,” the British commander of NATO forces in the south, Maj. Gen. Nick Carter, told reporters recently. In other words, the domino theory, Afghan-style.

Previous Post

The Misinformants

Next Post

Indonesia volcano erupts for first time in 400 years

ToP

ToP

Related Posts

indian pm modi
Pakistan

Pakistan Invites Indian PM Narendra Modi to SCO Meeting

by Jameel Ahmad
August 29, 2024
Largest IT Outage
Technology

Largest IT Outage in History Brings Y2K Fears to Reality, Says Web Security Expert

by Jameel Ahmad
July 19, 2024
Ishaq Dar
Pakistan

Ensure the Safety of Students”: Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar’s Directive Amid Bangladesh Protests

by Jameel Ahmad
July 18, 2024
Trump Assassination Attempt
International News

Trump Calls for Unity After Assassination Attempt

by Jameel Ahmad
July 15, 2024
Narendra Modi Government
International News

India shares plunge as polls show Modi’s mandate slipping

by Jameel Ahmad
June 4, 2024
Ebrahim Raisi
International News

Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi Confirmed Dead in Helicopter Crash

by Jameel Ahmad
May 20, 2024
Shehbaz Sharif
Pakistan

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif Garners New Investment Promises from Riyadh

by Jameel Ahmad
April 29, 2024
Next Post

Indonesia volcano erupts for first time in 400 years

Popular Stories

  • Akhtar Abbasi Shot Dead

    Akhtar Abbasi Shot Dead in Sukkur

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 10 Best Female Singers of Pakistan

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Time of Pakistan

About Times Of Pakistan

kralbetbetturkeyikimislibahis1xbetm.infohipas.infohttps://www.wiibet.com/restbetcdn.com

Other Categories

  • Beautiful Pakistan
  • Fashion News
  • Funny News
  • Viral Videos
  • Weird News

Recent Posts

  • 11th J.A. Zaman Memorial Open – Powered by Gem Golfers
  • Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to Jail in £190 Million Case
  • World’s Largest Submarine Cable Arrives in Pakistan: Could This End Internet Woes?

Times Of Pakistan © 2024. Design & Developed by E2E Solution Providers.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Pakistan
  • International News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In